Why Leaders Must Communicate Effectively in a Crisis
To communicate effectively in a crisis as a leader is one of the most critical skills in today’s high-stakes environment. Whether facing media scrutiny, internal scandal, or public backlash, the strength of your communication defines how your leadership is perceived – and whether trust is preserved or lost.
Stakeholders – employees, customers, investors, journalists – don’t just watch what you do. They listen closely to what you say and how you say it. In these moments, silence, vagueness or detachment can cost more than any operational failure.
The Real Cost of Communication Failures
Crisis itself doesn’t destroy a brand – poor communication does. And too often, leaders make fundamental mistakes:
-
They wait too long to speak.
-
They rely on generic, PR-driven language.
-
They fail to show empathy or accountability.
As a result, they lose the trust of their people, their public, and often, their position.
“If a CEO doesn’t speak during a crisis, the crisis speaks for them – and it rarely speaks kindly.”
— Dr. Nikolai A. Behr, Communication: Leadership Task No. 1
Lessons from Public Leadership Mistakes
Example 1: The Silent CEO
A German entrepreneur gave a careless, intoxicated interview that went viral. Despite advice from crisis consultants, he refused to act quickly. When negative headlines followed, banks pulled credit lines and his company collapsed. Over 500 employees lost their jobs.
Mistake: Vanity, poor judgment, and ignoring expert advice
Lesson: Surrounding yourself with advisors is not enough. You must also listen.
Example 2: Volkswagen’s Emissions Scandal
When VW’s emissions cheating became public in 2015, their initial response was vague: “irregularities.” This delayed and defensive messaging damaged their credibility. CEO Martin Winterkorn eventually stepped forward, expressing shock but stopping short of accepting blame. Many saw his apology as too little, too late.
His successor, Herbert Diess, took a different route: proactive communication on platforms like LinkedIn, clear messaging on transformation, and visibility in the media. It helped rebuild trust in the brand.
Mistake: Hesitation, evasion, lack of clarity
Lesson: Timely, authentic communication protects leadership and brand value.
Communicate Effectively in a Crisis: What Great Leaders Do
To communicate effectively in a crisis as a leader, you must act with speed, clarity, and authenticity. Here’s what separates successful crisis communicators from the rest:
1. Speak Early – Even Without All the Facts
People don’t expect perfection. They expect honesty. Saying “We don’t have all the answers, but here’s what we know” shows leadership.
2. Be the Face of the Message
Delegating crisis communication to PR teams sends the wrong signal. Leaders must be visible, human, and engaged.
3. Embrace the Media as a Platform
Trying to avoid journalists or control the narrative often backfires. Transparency earns respect and balanced reporting.
4. Show Empathy and Responsibility
Avoid robotic statements. Express concern, acknowledge fears, and take real accountability where it’s due.
5. Prepare Before the Crisis Hits
Effective crisis communication begins long before a scandal. Media training, scenario planning, and messaging frameworks ensure you can act fast and confidently when pressure mounts.
Core Principles of Leadership Communication in Crises
-
Speed builds trust. Delays create suspicion. Respond within 24 hours.
-
Presence matters. Be seen. People need a leader, not a spokesperson.
-
Clarity is strength. Avoid jargon. Speak like a human.
-
Empathy leads. Address emotion as much as fact.
-
Consistency wins. One message, one voice – internally and externally.
Final Thought: Leadership Is Communication Under Pressure
To communicate effectively in a crisis as a leader is not just a skill – it’s your leadership in action. Your words shape how people experience your values, your courage, and your competence. And in moments of uncertainty, your communication becomes the foundation of future trust.
Need to Strengthen Your Leadership Communication?
Work with us to prepare your leadership team for high-stakes communication. We offer executive coaching, media training, and tailored strategy support – confidential and results-driven.
👉 Book a private session with Dr. Nikolai A. Behr and the team at DIKT Media Training Institute
📞 0700 CALL-BEHR
📧 office@medientraining-institut.de
